Asymmetric Autonomy and the Settlement of Ethnic Conflicts by Marc Weller, Katherine Nobbs

By Marc Weller, Katherine Nobbs

Throughout the realm many sovereign states supply a number of in their territories larger autonomy than different parts. This association, referred to as uneven autonomy, has been followed with better regularity as an answer to ethnic strife and secessionist struggles in fresh a long time. As uneven autonomy turns into essentially the most usually used clash answer equipment, exam of the confident and unfavorable outcomes of its implementation, in addition to its efficacy, is vital.

Asymmetric Autonomy and the payment of Ethnic Conflicts assesses the power of such strength distribution preparations to solve violent struggles among important governments and separatist teams. This number of new case reports from around the globe covers a number of vital advancements, from recentralization in Russia, to "one state, structures" in China, to constitutional innovation in Iraq. As a complete, those essays research how good uneven autonomy agreements can convey protracted and bloody conflicts to an finish, fulfill the calls for of each side, warrantly the actual integrity of a country, and confirm peace and balance. individuals to this publication additionally study the numerous difficulties and dilemmas which could come up while self sufficient areas are shaped. for instance, powers should be loosely outlined or unrealistically assigned to the kingdom inside a country. Redrawn barriers can create new minorities and make different teams liable to human rights violations. Given the variety of constrained self-determination platforms in position, the essays during this quantity current different reviews of those political structures.

Asymmetric nation agreements have the capability to therapy a few of humanity's so much intractable disputes. In Asymmetric Autonomy and the cost of Ethnic Conflicts, major political scientists and diplomatic specialists shed new mild at the useful outcomes of those settlements and provide refined frameworks for knowing this direction towards lasting peace.

Show description

Read Online or Download Asymmetric Autonomy and the Settlement of Ethnic Conflicts PDF

Similar diplomacy books

The Principle of Mutual Recognition in the European Integration Process

Mutual reputation (MR) signifies that each one Member nation is unfastened to take advantage of the factors for construction it prefers yet can't inhibit the import from different Member States lawfully utilizing different criteria, except justified through emergency purposes. the house nation rule then prevails at the host kingdom. obstacles to access curb, festival rises within the inner marketplace.

Franco-Irish Relations, 1500-1610: Politics, Migration and Trade (Royal Historical Society Studies in History New Series)

The interval 1500 to 1610 witnessed a basic transformation within the nature of Franco-Irish relatives. In 1500 touch was once solely in response to alternate and small-scale migration. in spite of the fact that, from the early 1520s to the early 1580s, the dynamics of 'normal' kin have been considerably altered as remarkable political contacts among eire and France have been cultivated.

American Exceptionalism and the Legacy of Vietnam: US Foreign Policy since 1974

American Exceptionalism and the Legacy of Vietnam examines the effect of the idea in American exceptionalism at the historical past of U. S. overseas coverage because the Vietnam battle. Trevor B. McCrisken analyzes makes an attempt by means of every one post-Vietnam U. S. management to restore the preferred trust in exceptionalism either rhetorically and through pursuing overseas coverage supposedly grounded in conventional American rules.

Additional info for Asymmetric Autonomy and the Settlement of Ethnic Conflicts

Example text

A number of aspects, however, can and need to be specified in the context of the analysis of the two classical examples of asymmetric territorial autonomy regimes, the Aaland Islands and South Tyrol. As noted by Weller, for states asymmetry offers an opportunity to maintain the overall state structure. For example, states can avoid the dreaded “f-word” federalization. Embracing asymmetry, moreover, endows institutional architects with a significant degree of flexibility to cater to the very specific situational characteristics that a conflict might bring with it and that need to be addressed in its settlement.

Their members are the president, vice-president, one of the presidency’s secretaries, and four or five “ordinary” members chosen by government and opposition parties in the assembly, again reflecting ethnic proportions in the assembly. indd 37 3/17/10 12:01:37 PM 38 Stefan Wolff At the regional level, and again unique in the Italian context, similar provisions were made to ensure adequate representation of the German and Italian ethnic groups, and thus, by extension, a functioning system of power sharing.

Only in one respect has a more or less formal veto right been established: in relation to the provincial and regional budgets. Here, separate majorities are required from both ethnic groups. If this is not forthcoming, all chapters of the budget are voted on individually. Those failing to receive the required double majority are referred to a special commission of the assembly, and if no agreement is reached the administrative court in Bozen/Bolzano makes a final and binding decision. In this sense, power-sharing arrangements not only add a dimension of asymmetry per se but also affect the way other aspects of asymmetry (in this case legislative power) operate.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.25 of 5 – based on 28 votes